(419) 526-2669


Jim and Cathy Smith

Already successful restaurateurs, the Smiths bought Coney Island Diner in 1992. While renovating the diner, the couple continued to operate their first restaurant, Smittys, located on the square. They ran the two concurrently for a while, but in 1996 they decided to close Smitty’s after 10 great years, and focused entirely on Coney Island Diner.

The Diner

Coney Island Diner is Mansfield, Ohio’s oldest operating restaurant. Opened by a Greek immigrant in 1919, and moved to it’s current location in 1936, the restaurant has been a Mansfield tradition for as long as any living Mansfielders can remember.

Most of the fixtures are original or restored, the lights are even replicas of the originals. The Smith family has made every effort to restore the restaurant to it’s original, classic diner decor.

The Food

The menu features classic American diner fare with a few contemporary favorites. Their legendary coney sauce has been the most popular in town since 1919